Monday, March 15, 2010
Approval Not Required and Zoning Freezes
It really is amazing that one can vest "rights" for something that has not been even conceived in ones imagination. This truly illustrates the need to do away with the "Approval Not Required Plan".
Friday, January 30, 2009
Personal Thoughts on the Land Use Partnership Act - Local Land Use Regulation Affecting Certified Plan Communities.
III. MODIFICATIONS TO LOCAL LAND USE REGULATION AFFECTING CERTIFIED PLAN COMMUNITIES
1) ANR, minor subdivision review
Insert the following new paragraphs within Section 81L of Chapter 41:
“Certified plan community” shall have the meaning set forth in Section [2] of Chapter 41.
This change is simple enough, giving Certified Plan Communities recognition within Chapter 41.
“Minor subdivision review ” shall mean an alternative method of approval under the subdivision control law, applicable to any proposed division of a tract of land into four or fewer lots, under which: (a) no preliminary plan is required; (b) approval is granted by a simple majority of the planning board; (c) decisions are made within 60 days, or else deemed constructively approved, as defined in Section [2] of Chapter 41; (c) approval shall be based solely on the compliance of the lots shown with reasonable rules and regulations regarding the adequacy of access, utilities and stormwater drainage controls and on the compliance of the lots shown with the zoning ordinance or by-law; and (d) such rules and regulations may include a requirement that two or more of the lots have shared access to an existing public way, but may not impose design or construction requirements on such shared access other than those minimally necessary to provide for public safety. Lots approved under minor subdivision review may not be re-subdivided so as to create additional lots under minor subdivision review for a period of ten years after initial approval.
Here the proposal is to add a new definition for plans subjected to Minor Subdivision Review. We are in a definition section, this definition reads like it could be applied in any community. The definition should be changed to add reference to the community being a Certified Plan Community. This really should be right up front, I would suggest that the change be made in the opening clause such that it might read "“Minor subdivision review ” shall mean an alternative method of approval in Certified Plan Communities under the subdivision control law...."
Modify the definition of “subdivision” within Section 81L of Chapter 41 as follows:
“Subdivision” shall mean the division of a tract of land into two or more lots and shall include resubdivision, and, when appropriate to the context, shall relate to the process of subdivision or the land or territory subdivided; provided, however, unless a municipality is a certified plan community and has in effect minor subdivision review procedures, that the division of a tract of land into two or more lots shall not be deemed to constitute a subdivision within the meaning of the subdivision control law if, at the time when it is made, every lot within the tract so divided has frontage on (a) a public way or a way which the clerk of the city or town certifies is maintained and used as a public way, or (b) a way shown on a plan theretofore approved and endorsed in accordance with the subdivision control law, or (c) a way in existence when the subdivision control law became effective in the city or town in which the land lies, having, in the opinion of the planning board, sufficient width, suitable grades and adequate construction to provide for the needs of vehicular traffic in relation to the proposed use of the land abutting thereon or served thereby, and for the installation of municipal services to serve such land and the buildings erected or to be erected thereon. Such frontage shall be of at least such distance as is then required by zoning or other ordinance or by-law, if any, of said city or town for erection of a building on such lot, and if no distance is so required, such frontage shall be of at least twenty feet. If a municipality is a certified plan community and has in effect minor subdivision review procedures, then any division of a tract of land into two or more lots, including resubdivision, shall be deemed to constitute a subdivision within the meaning of the subdivision control law, except as provided in the following sentence. Conveyances or other instruments adding to, taking away from, or changing the size and shape of, lots in such a manner as not to leave any lot so affected without the frontage above set forth, or the division of a tract of land on which two or more buildings were standing when the subdivision control law went into effect in the city or town in which the land lies into separate lots on each of which one of such buildings remains standing, shall not constitute a subdivision. Within a certified plan community that has adopted minor subdivision review procedures as of the municipality’s effective date, a tract of land that was divided into two or more lots pursuant to Chapter 41, Section 81P of the General Laws prior to the municipality’s effective date, but after December 1, 2008, shall be deemed a subdivision within the meaning of the subdivision control law with respect to the lots so created for which a building permit has not been issued by the municipality prior to the municipality’s effective date.
This section has the verbiage that should have been included in the previous definition change.
The final change deals with adding additional verbiage to Chapter 40A Section 6. Outside of the fact that Section 6 is already long, tedious and difficult to read, the additional wording really only applies to communities with certified plans and reads as follows:
2) Zoning plan freeze
Insert the following new paragraph after the new paragraphs that follow the new paragraphs of Section 6 of Chapter 40A (see I(A)(6) above):
Within a municipality that is a certified plan community, if a declaration of development intent is submitted to a planning board on or after the municipality’s effective date, and written notice of such submission has been given to the city or town clerk, the development described in such declaration shall be governed by the applicable provisions of the zoning ordinance or by-law and all other local land use regulations, if any, in effect at the time of such written notice of submission, for a vesting period that ends either: (a) three years from the date of such written notice of submission, or (b) to the extent the land shown on the plan has been previously been disturbed, and if there has been substantial investment in site preparation and/or infrastructure construction within such three years, five years from the date of such written notice of submission; provided that (i) the development described in such declaration shall be subject to subsequent amendment of the zoning ordinance or by-law or of any other local land use regulations, if the first notice thereof was posted prior to the date of such written notice of submission, and (ii) the development described in such declaration shall be subject to subsequent amendment of the zoning ordinance or by-law or of any other local land use regulations, unless a definitive plan, or a preliminary plan followed within seven months by a definitive plan, is submitted to a planning board for approval under the subdivision control law prior to such amendment, and, if such definitive plan or an amendment thereof is thereafter finally approved. Whatever the length of such vesting period, it shall be extended by a period equal to the time which a city or town imposes or has imposed upon it by a state, a federal agency or a court, a moratorium on construction, the issuance of permits or utility connections. The provisions of this paragraph shall not apply to development substantially different in use or substantially greater in extent from the development described in the declaration of development intent.
All the proposed changes in this section provide relief to communities with certified plans. I am not really sure whether the change from Approval Not Required to Minor Subdivision Approval is really all that big a change. It would be great to have the extra time and the requirement that the lots comply with zoning, which ANR lots do not have to do, but the costs associated with getting certification may be too great a burden.
Similarly the zoning freeze change to only three years, over the current eight sounds great, but the other changes that are proposed, the letter of intent to develop, the minimum two year life of a permit, etc, are, again, too great a cost.
The final section of the proposed act, Section 4, deals with providing funding, outside of the fact that $1,000,000 will provide far too little funding for communities to develop these plans, I really do not have anything to say.
Anyway, thanks for listening to my month long rant on this proposal. Hopefully it will open up some eyes, get the committee that crafted this looking at the proposal from the local level, and withdraw it to re-write the act.
Sunday, January 18, 2009
Personal Thoughts on the Land Use Partnership Act - Modification to Subdivision Control (Part 2)
I provided a teaser to this discussion in my previous post. The Land Use Partnership Act includes a proposal to limit appeals of subdivision approvals. The exact wording is:
2) Limitations on appeals.
Modify the first paragraph of Section 81BB of Chapter 41 as follows:
Section 81BB. Any person, whether or not previously a party to the proceedings, or any municipal officer or board, aggrieved by a decision of a board of appeals under section eighty-one Y, or by any decision of a planning board concerning a plan of a subdivision of land, or by the failure of such a board to take final action concerning such a plan within the required time, may appeal to the superior court for the county in which said land is situated or to the land court; provided, that such appeal is entered within twenty days after such decision has been recorded in the office of the city or town clerk or within twenty days after the expiration of the required time as aforesaid, as the case may be, and notice of such appeal is given to such city or town clerk so as to be received within such twenty days. The court shall hear all pertinent evidence and determine the facts, and upon the facts so determined, shall annul such decision if found to exceed the authority of such board, or make such other decree as justice and equity may require. The foregoing remedy shall be exclusive, but the parties shall have all rights of appeal and exceptions as in other equity cases. A complaint by a plaintiff challenging a subdivision approval under this section shall allege the specific reasons why the subdivision fails to satisfy the requirements of the board’s rules and regulations or other applicable law and allege specific facts establishing how the plaintiff is aggrieved by such decision. The board’s decision in such a case shall be affirmed unless the court concludes the board abused its discretion in approving the subdivision.
This section is as significant for what it removes as for what it adds. The removal of the court being empowered to hear the entire case and to substitute its own judgement for that of the Boar is significant. This existing wording provides protection to both the developer and the abutters. Either one needs to present its case to the court, whether challenging an approval or a denial of a subdivision. Ultimately leaving the court in the position to determine if the law has been followed.
The change deals only with approval of a subdivision. It tilts the table in support of decisions to approve projects. The process for appealing a denial is left as is. This places a community in a position of having to provide a greater level of proof that a denial is appropriate than for an approval.
So, this act essentially establishes mandatory determinations for judges upon challenges to subdivision approvals. It seems we want to give the public as little rights in the process as we can. Seems like we are heading down the path of our neighbor to the north which allows only 30 days to challenge a building permit which violates zoning, even though the builder does not have to start building until the 30 days are over. Many of the sections proposed for modification in the Land Use Partnership Act should be left alone. This is one such illustration. I have seen no problems in the courts operating under the current legal framework. Obviously this change stems from developers who feel that the judicial system is too burdensome and abutters should have no rights. Look closely, it only deals with dismissing complaints for subdivision approvals! It would seem that similar deferral to the board’s decision should be made for denials, but it is not. Awful, awful, awful, very anti-community and anti-abutter.
This particular issue is also not just a planner's issue. It is an issue for every resident of the state. The change is limiting the legal rights of abutters to challenge what may be an incorrect decision. And, the incorrect action may not be the basis of the reason for the court upholding its decision, only whether the Board abused its discretion.
Saturday, January 17, 2009
Personal Thoughts on the Land Use Partnership Act - Modifications to Subdivision Control (Part 1)
Completing this discussion has become even more urgent. In today's Boston Globe it was reported that the Governor's Office has submitted legislation to change the "arcane" zoning statute. It has now reached the critical point for communities to rally and tell their legislators that the administration's proposed zoning amendments are not what cities and towns have been asking for. We need to demand that the administration withdraw its proposal which simply confuses the discussion of zoning reform.
The administration change to the Subdivision Control Act are "minor" in the amount of words actually changes. However, the change is major if you are a resident of a community with any significant land area available to be subdivided. The following is the proposed wording in the proposed act:
B) Modifications to Chapter 41 (subdivision review)
1) Planning board rules and regulations
Modify Section 81Q of Chapter 41 as follows:
Section 81Q. After a public hearing, notice of the time and place of which, and of the subject matter, sufficient for identification, shall be published in a newspaper of general circulation in the city or town once in each of two successive weeks, the first publication to be not less than fourteen days before the day of the hearing or if there is no such newspaper in such city or town then by posting such notice in a conspicuous place in the city or town hall for a period of not less than fourteen days before the day of such hearing, a planning board shall adopt, and, in the same manner, may, from time to time, amend, reasonable rules and regulations relative to subdivision control not inconsistent with the subdivision control law or with any other provisions of a statute or of any valid ordinance or by-law of the city or town. Such rules and regulations may prescribe the size, form, contents, style and number of copies of plans and the procedure for the submission and approval thereof, and shall be such as to enable the person submitting the plan to comply with the requirements of the register of deeds for the recording of the same, and to assure the board of a copy for its files; and shall set forth the requirements of the board with respect to the location, construction, width and grades of the proposed ways shown on a plan and the installation of municipal services therein, which requirements shall be established in such manner as to carry out the purposes of the subdivision control law as set forth in section eighty-one M. Such rules and regulations shall not require referral of a subdivision plan to any other board or person prior to its submission to the planning board. In establishing such requirements regarding ways, due regard shall be paid to the prospective character of different subdivisions, whether open residence, dense residence, business or industrial, and the prospective amount of travel upon the various ways therein, and to adjustment of the requirements accordingly; provided, however, that in no case shall a city or town establish rules or regulations regarding the laying out, construction, alteration, or maintenance of ways within a particular subdivision which exceed the standards and criteria commonly applied by that city or town to the laying out, construction, alteration, or maintenance of its publicly financed ways located in similarly zoned districts within such city or town. Without limiting the foregoing, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that such requirements are unlawfully excessive, to the extent that the requirements for subdivisions within zoning districts having a minimum lot size of 40,000 square feet exceed the standards and criteria previously applied by that city or town to the laying out, construction, alteration, or maintenance of ways within previously approved subdivisions within zoning districts having a minimum lot size of 20,000 square feet or less.. Such rules and regulations may set forth a requirement that a turnaround be provided at the end of the approved portion of a way which does not connect with another way. Any easement in any turnaround shown on a plan approved under the subdivision control law which arises after January first, nineteen hundred and sixty, other than an easement appurtenant to a lot abutting the turnaround, shall terminate upon the approval and recording of a plan showing extension of said way, except in such portion of said turnaround as is included in said extension, and the recording of a certificate by the planning board of the construction of such extension. Such rules and regulations may set forth a requirement that underground distribution systems be provided for any and all utility services, including electrical and telephone services, as may be specified in such rules and regulations, and may set forth a requirement that poles and any associated overhead structures, of a design approved by the planning board, be provided for use for police and fire alarm boxes and any similar municipal equipment and for use for street lighting. The rules and regulations may encourage the use of solar energy systems and protect to the extent feasible the access to direct sunlight of solar energy systems. Such rules and regulations may include standards for the orientation of new streets, lots and buildings; building set back requirements from property lines; limitations on the type, height and placement, of vegetation; and restrictive covenants protecting solar access not inconsistent with existing local ordinances or by-laws. Except in so far as it may require compliance with the requirements of existing [zoning] ordinances or by-laws, no rule or regulation shall relate to the size, shape, width, frontage or use of lots within a subdivision, or to the buildings which may be constructed thereon, or other subject matters addressed thereby, or shall be inconsistent with the regulations and requirements of any other municipal board acting within its jurisdiction. No rule or regulation shall require, and no planning board shall impose, as a condition for the approval of a plan of a subdivision, that any of the land within said subdivision be dedicated to the public use, or conveyed or released to the commonwealth or to the county, city or town in which the subdivision is located, for use as a public way, public park or playground, or for any other public purpose, without just compensation to the owner thereof. The rules and regulations may, however, provide that not more than one building designed or available for use for dwelling purposes shall be erected or placed or converted to use as such on any lot in a subdivision, or elsewhere in the city or town, without the consent of the planning board, and that such consent may be conditional upon the providing of adequate ways furnishing access to each site for such building, in the same manner as otherwise required for lots within a subdivision. No rule or regulation shall require, and no planning board shall impose, as a condition for the approval of a plan of a subdivision, the payment or performance of off-site mitigation, except for the imposition of a development impact fee under Chapter 40A, Section 9D. A true copy of the rules and regulations, with their most recent amendments, shall be kept on file available for inspection in the office of the planning board of the city or town by which they were adopted, and in the office of the clerk of such city or town. A copy certified by such clerk of any such rules and regulations, or any amendment thereof, adopted after the first day of January, nineteen hundred and fifty-four shall be transmitted forthwith by such planning board to the register of deeds and recorder of the land court. Once a definitive plan has been submitted to a planning board, and written notice has been given to the city or town clerk pursuant to section eighty-one T and until final action has been taken thereon by the planning board or the time for such action prescribed by section eighty-one U has elapsed, the rules and regulations governing such plan shall be those in effect relative to subdivision control at the time of the submission of such plan. When a preliminary plan referred to in section eighty-one S has been submitted to a planning board, and written notice of the submission of such plan has been given to the city or town clerk, such preliminary plan and the definitive plan evolved therefrom shall be governed by the rules and regulations relative to subdivision control in effect at the time of the submission of the preliminary plan, provided that the definitive plan is duly submitted within seven months from the date on which the preliminary plan was submitted.
Pulling no punches, the changes proposed here are, again, horrendous. Let's start with the changes affecting roadway design.
Without limiting the foregoing, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that such requirements are unlawfully excessive, to the extent that the requirements for subdivisions within zoning districts having a minimum lot size of 40,000 square feet exceed the standards and criteria previously applied by that city or town to the laying out, construction, alteration, or maintenance of ways within previously approved subdivisions within zoning districts having a minimum lot size of 20,000 square feet or less..
Why should the state establish a limit on roadway design? This section essentially establishes that, if a town has 40,000 sf lot sizes and modifies its roadway design standards the changes are assumed to be exclusionary and the town must be prepared to defend its application of these new standards. Personally and professionally I have many problems with this proposal and the assumptions used.
First, the state is turning the Subdivision Control Act into a weapon against the cities and towns. The Subdivision Control Act is intended for communities to guide the development of the town and to coordinate the location and construction of ways, according to a plan, per the requirements of Chapter 41 Section 81D. The proposed change automatically assumes that the town's establishment of street standards are flawed, if the town has large lot sizes. Thus the coordination of ways aspect of the Subdivision Control Act is taken away from the town and essentially turned over to any developer choosing to challenge the town's subdivision road standards.
Second, many communities adopted 40,000 sf lot sizes long before anyone had any concept of what a proper road design standard should be. Why should the state now decide to tie a limit on roadway design standards to a set of standards which may not meet modern roadway construction? Some towns established 20,000 sf lot sizes in the 1950’s and paid no attention to roadway construction standards. This would essentially say that these sections of town could revert to dirt roads for subdivisions.
Further on in this section, the issue of off-site improvements once again raises its ugly head.
No rule or regulation shall require, and no planning board shall impose, as a condition for the approval of a plan of a subdivision, the payment or performance of off-site mitigation, except for the imposition of a development impact fee under Chapter 40A, Section 9D.
Essentially the provisions establish that the only mechanism for addressing off-site issues will be through impact fees. This has many problems. First, improvements at a subdivision intersection could be considered off-site. Sidewalks and turn lanes along the frontage could also be considered off-site, but would be necessitated by the development in question. In many other discussions of public health, energy conservation, etc, the state has raised the issue that people do not walk, do not have safe places to walk, and so on. The provisions of this section would limit the ability of a community to require a site to connect its sidewalks to adjacent - off-site sidewalks, especially since we are prohibited from considering any dedications of area for public use within a subdivision (essentially requiring the sidewalks to be provided on-site. Again, this is totally illogical and flies in the face of proper land planning, and planning for the connection of public facilities.
Given the limited ability to deny subdivisions, it would seem that these restrictions place communities even further behind the 8-ball.
Another aspect is the idea that perhaps a development, without particular improvements would be “premature and scattered” a concept in the original zoning enabling act that is not present in Chapter 40A, Chapter 41 or this proposal. The “premature and scattered” provisions can be used to allow a town to deny a project when the road capacity or sewer service or water service, etc. is not available to serve the subdivision. The alternative to a “premature and scattered” finding is a requirement for an applicant to provide a particular improvement. So, a project outside a sewer improvement district might extend the sewer line to its property out of pocket in order to be approved. The provisions of this section completely prohibit that approach. Essentially a one-size fits all solution being imposed on 351 communities.
The next discussion should cause all the citizens of the Commonwealth to jump up and down. The proposal to be discussed is the one to limit appeals, and to establish that board approvals must be given special consideration as being correct.